Could a Roth IRA be Better Than a 401(k)?

Very few people whom I know are familiar with the benefits of the Roth IRA. It was named for the late Senator William Roth of Rhode Island, who proposed it. It is similar to a traditional IRA except contributions are never tax-deductible. Contributions to traditional IRAs are sometimes deductible or partially deductible, depending on your income and whether or not you have a retirement plan like a 401(k) at work. With Roth IRAs, individuals are limited to incomes of $95,000 ($150,000 for couples) to be eligible for full contribution amounts.

However, unlike the traditional IRA, you can withdraw your contributions from a Roth IRA at any time, at any age without penalty. Earnings are not taxed if you wait until at least age 59 1/2 to begin withdrawing them and have held your Roth IRA for at least five years. With a Roth IRA, the contributions are taxed without any deferment, but they grow tax-free and the gains are never taxed (see above). With a 401(k), contributions are tax-deferred, but eventually the contributions and gains will be taxed. By the time most people retire, the earnings from their retirement accounts will far exceed their contributions, due to compounding. With that in mind, one could make the case for a Roth IRA possibly being better than a 401(k).

Here's an illustration. Let's suppose that over the course of 25 years you contributed a total of $75,000 to your 401(k) and your employer kicked in $30,000 during that same period for a total of $105,000. By the end of those 25 years, your compounded gains (assuming you're getting a decent rate of return) could total $500,000. When you retire, you will eventually pay taxes on the entire $605,000 as well as the gains you receive from it after retirement. Now, let's assume that, instead of contributing to your 401(k) for those 25 years, you contributed only $50,000 to your Roth IRA (without a matching contribution from your employer, of course). The assumption is also that you would not be able to contribute as much because you are using post-tax dollars for the Roth IRA vs. pre-tax dollars for the 401(k). However, because you generally have more investment options with the Roth IRA money than with the 401(k) money, you are likely to find a better rate of return. With that in mind, let's say your compounded gains could total $400,000. When you retire, you could have the entire $450,000 as well as the gains you could receive from it post-retirement, completely tax free!

As you can see, it is possible that many people could come out better putting at least a portion of their retirement funds into a Roth IRA. Judge for yourself. I actually contribute more to my Roth IRA than I do to my 401(k). I put just enough into my 401(k) to get my employer's maximum matching contribution, and that's all. However, I'm not a financial advisor and I don't play one on TV, so check with your financial advisor to see what would be right for you. For more information about the Roth IRA, see the following link: http://www.rothira.com.

Terry Mitchell is a software engineer, freelance writer, and trivia buff from Hopewell, VA. He also serves as a political columnist for American Daily and operates his own website - http://www.commenterry.com - on which he posts commentaries on various subjects such as politics, technology, religion, health and well-being, personal finance, and sports. His commentaries offer a unique point of view that is not often found in mainstream media.


Free Quran in All Languages

Free Tafsir Books

What Are Your Beliefs About Money and Wealth?

What is your attitude towards having wealth? Do you believe... Read More

My Ambitious Niche - A Completely NEW Way To Find Ambitious Wealth

Turn to the year 1999, a couple of friends sitting... Read More

WARNING: The Biggest Lie About Social Security

Like I said, If you are poor and on social... Read More

The Three Step Plan To Prosperity

You have $100 in your bank account, your rent is... Read More

16 Mantras for Building Financial Wealth

Everyone wants to be wealthy, but most of us do... Read More

Offshore Strategies & Services

Offshore strategies may or may not be right for you.... Read More

Start A Cashflow Club

The cashflow board games, Cashflow 101, Cashflow 202, and Cashflow... Read More

How to Make More Money

When I was a student in London, I had a... Read More

Investors - What Separates the Good Traders from the Bad Traders?

There are many forms of investing online. While I can... Read More

One Pipeline Is Worth A Thousand Paychecks

It is with great pleasure of having you here at... Read More

Thieves Continue to Pull Off the Biggest Heist in History?Until Now!

Imagine being able to steal untold millions of dollars in... Read More

How To Get Investors And Bankers To Part With Their Money For Your Business

Time and time again entrepreneurs are losing out on getting... Read More

Do You want to Live on Macaroni and Cheese when You Retire or Filet Mignon?

How Much Money Will I Need to Earn to Retire?This... Read More

Don?t Work for Your Money, Make it Work for You!

Well, the New Year is around the corner and so... Read More

Profit from Your Own Information Empire!

Would you like to profit from your own information empire?... Read More

Turn That Fixed Rate Mortgage Into A Goldmine

When you purchased your home, you most likely got a... Read More

Do You Want To Save Money Easily?

Living on credit is fashionable. Indulging oneself is fashionable. Saving... Read More

Tax Help - Girls (and Guys) Just Want to Have Fun by Using Tax Saving Tips

In his best selling book, "Rich Dad, Poor Dad, Robert... Read More

Early Retirement The Dream of the Working Classes

Everyone dreams of early retirement. The idea of no longer... Read More

7 Golden Rules to Financial Prosperity

Not Enough Money?I believe that most people haven't got enough... Read More

Investing is About Discipline

If you don't have discipline then walk away from the... Read More

How To Grow Your Mental Power and Let Your Brain Make You Rich

No one has complete control over their thoughts. But with... Read More

Learn To Budget

Do you like so many others feel, that even if... Read More

Wealth Secrets: Saving Your Way to a Fortune

SCENE 1: Pharaoh has just woken up from a very... Read More

Money Myths Of The Poor

From tender age, we were exposed to myths about money... Read More